Risk of Church Losing Tax Exempt Status?

by Phil Collins
(Houston, Texas)

Many years ago, I kept the accounting records (books) for about 25 small businesses, each one with a very different product or service.

A clear reality that I learned from that experience and have never forgotten was the number one risk of failure for a business, large or small. Some may say poor decisions regarding financing, or overextending the business and other reasons can cause a business to fail.

These and other reasons are valid. But I still maintain, especially after having worked 38 years in the accounting profession, that the highest risk is the absence of approved written internal controls. Why do most audit programs have review of internal controls as the first step?

Now in my part time position as the bookkeeper for a local church, I am again seeing the matter of internal controls being at the center of not so much the failure of the church like a business would fail, but the risk of losing their tax exempt status.

Very much like the owners of the small business which I serviced, the people in the church are good people and I am convinced have no intent of knowingly doing something to lose their tax exempt status.

The church has a number of designated funds that are reported on the balance sheet. A number of the funds represent small groups or Sunday school classes. The church receives contributions that are designated to the small groups or funds and over time the balance in these accounts can grow to large amounts.

Recently a check request was received from one of these small groups to withdraw $3,000 from "their" fund. The check was to be made out to the name of the small group which is the same name of the fund listed on the balance sheet.

Not until after the check request was approved did I begin to have concerns and questions. The basis of my first concern was that the contributions made by the individuals that makes up the $3,000 was done so with the intent to take a tax deduction on their income tax return since their contribution was being made to a 501(c) (3) non-profit organization, a church but now those funds were being moved to an entity outside the church.

After the funds are moved out of the churches bank account, the church no longer has control over how the funds will be spent. How do internal controls fit this situation? If the church has written approved policies and procedures that addresses and explains this transfer, steps for oversight and follow-up and audit, there may be a basis to make the transfer. But no written approved policies and procedures exist.

My second concern was how did the small group endorse the check? When the check cleared the bank, I got a copy of the front and back of the check from the bank website and my concerns deepened.

Included in the endorsement was not only the name of the small group but the name of the church was part of their endorsement, in other words, the small group was holding themselves out not only as a group of people commonly bound but connected to the church.

How do internal controls fit this situation? To-date I am not aware nor found that the church has any written approved policies and procedures for opening bank accounts by the church or small groups in the name of the church.

My recent experience with opening new business accounts with banks, regardless for profit or not for profit organizations, is very involved. So how and on what basis did the bank open the account for this small group without officially contacting the church and requesting official signatures from the church treasurer and other church officials?

Where is the risk in losing tax exempt status?

Not maintaining necessary internal controls, protection (safe keeping) of contributions and controls of oversight of disbursements of contributions, resulting in tax deductible contributions ending up in an entity that is not tax exempt.

As stated earlier, I don’t believe any of the individuals in the small groups purposefully intend to violate any principal or law by their request for the funds to be transferred to their account.

What is, however, very clear is the appearance of wrong doing. To an outsider, whoever that person may be, this is a picture of the "old shell game".

Contributions are funneled into an exempt organization for tax deduction purposes and then moved out at a later date for purposes other than the mission of the not for profit organization, in other words tax fraud.

If the decision were mine to make about these matters, I would first ask the question, why is it necessary to move the money outside the church when the church has all the means (accounting system, etc.) to receive and disburse the funds?

Regardless of the answer, I would require all small group bank accounts to be closed and monies returned to the church. Why would I do this regardless of the answer, because there is not an acceptable answer to move money outside of the charitable organization who received the contributions in the first place.

Know the answer? Face the same situation? Please post your answer or comment by using the "comment" link below. Thank you!

Comments for Risk of Church Losing Tax Exempt Status?

Click here to add your own comments

Jul 09, 2010
Church Groups and Separate Checking Accounts
by: Kathy

I am the recording secretary for our church. I happen to agree with you about the groups having outside checking accounts being a "no-no".

If the groups are using the church's tax number to purchase items and not running the purchases through the church accounting system, they are in violation of the law.

If they have their own checking account they should have their own tax number.

Often groups think they can use the church's tax number simple because they are associated with the church and that is not so.

I have to agree with the fact that if the church is collecting that money for a dedicated fund, the church should have control to the fact the money is spent for that reason it was put in there.

If an IRS audit was to happen, I believe the red flags would be flying pretty high. You may need to address your concerns with a CPA about your situation and take them to your council as well.

Sometimes it is best to have your information well in hand when addressing these situations as people tend to get a little defensive when these issues are addressed.

Good luck.

Aug 05, 2010
Small Group Funds
by: Rebecca

When I came to be the Finance Secretary, we closed all small group bank accounts and transferred the funds to designated funds with the title of the class.

All deposits into these funds are entered as non deductible contributions. We make it known that if an individual would like to make a tax deductible donation it would have to be made to an account that the church controls the distribution of funds.

By entering them as non deductible contributions, they are allowed to spend the money however they see fit. We, however will not allow a check to be written to an individual without paid receipts as documentation.

Aug 05, 2010
Small Group Funds
by: Phil Collins

Excellent comments Rebecca. You must have solid support from your ministry staff to do what you did. Your actions are examples of needed internal controls that unfortunately lacking in many churches. In my situation, I don't have the support you have but the finance committee members are becoming more aware of tighter controls. Thanks for commenting.

Aug 09, 2010
Small Group Funds
by: Rebecca

It was a joint effort, and I am lucky to work with such a great team that listens to my concerns.

May 04, 2011
by: Anonymous

Excellent information and God Bless vickey for her dedication and willingness to help others.

Oct 14, 2012
The best way to take care of this matter
by: Terrice

On the back of all our church offering envelopes are printed these words: "All the tithes, offerings or other donations of any kind are under the control of this church. Using this envelope constitutes your agreement to relinquish control in accordance with IRS regulations. All gifts to the Best Church in Town, are tax deductible under the Internal Revenue Codes."

Jan 22, 2013
All Contributions are NOT Tax Deductible
by: Vickey

Terrice, I like the wording of the disclaimer you put on your offering envelopes; however, I confused by that last line in it: " All gifts to the Best Church in Town, are tax deductible under the Internal Revenue Codes." All gifts are not tax deductible such as contributions to an individual.

How do you handle that?

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Internal Controls.

If you want to DIY your payroll, I highly recommend you look at using Gusto! It is very user friendly and their support is awesome! Plus they know how to set up and maintain payrolls for churches and nonprofit organizations.

Note: I am a "partner" of Gusto, but as I have told you before ... I never recommend anything that we or our clients have not tried and love =)

Share this page:
Enjoy this page? Please pay it forward. Here's how...

Would you prefer to share this page with others by linking to it?

  1. Click on the HTML link code below.
  2. Copy and paste it, adding a note of your own, into your blog, a Web page, forums, a blog comment, your Facebook account, or anywhere that someone would find this page valuable.